Game One
- "I hear Jews are caused by demons." Nick
- "I'm pro that 'shunning' thing. I'll just start now." Theresa
- "I'm all for kicking down the door and dragging her kicking and screaming back into the flock." Amber
- "Need something a little weaker than water, there, do ya?" Theresa
- "Well, any man able to raise that much money is deserving of respect." Alex
- "Did you have any purpose coming here other than to insult my husband, myself, and my son." Neel
- "I want to erase what he just said from the record entirely!" Amber
- "You're just a tricked-out anti-heathen munchkin." Andrιs
- "I'm not fighting with an eight-year-old, just because I made his mother cry. You can go to Hell if you want." Alex
- "You don't convert people through kindness! You convert them through strong language!" Amber
- "No! We don't want them getting the extra dice from having their son involved! Think about this from a mechanics view!" Amber
- "Isn't a harlot just a woman heretic?" The kid who beat up Micah, son of the drunken woman
Game Two
- "She's kinda like dressed in a Mormon Burkha." Neel
- "I wanted to be proud of you, but I can't say that I am right now." Cyrus's Mother
- "She's demented; she whipped her mom!" "She deserved it!" Alex & Amber
- "I'm bored. And there's nothing more dangerous than a bored lawman. With two barrels of consecrated earth." OctoberBlack
- "And I had nothing to do with it!" Alex
- "I'm getting vilified now. And I was not the villain
for the first part of it." Amber
- "Be prepared, don't be ridiculous." OctoberBlack
- "The dutiful son honors the mother." "I'm trying, but she's not worthy of honor." The Book of Life & CyrusStark
- "I've been fighting the government all my life, 'cept when I was fighting Dogs. The Dogs won." Exhumations, currently a Dog
- "You're not a proper member of the Faith. Get out of my face before I beat your ass." Exhumations
- "Maybe the kid stabbed him. He was on a stabbing spree." Nick
- "He hit his head on the mantel" "Now, picking up the mantel and savagely beating him don't count." Elery & October
- "Motherfucker." "Yes, yes he is. That's exactly the problem." Joseph & Cyrus
- "I am shameless." Neel
- "All I can do is make you feel guilty." "You're good at that." "No you're not. Oh, wait, it's just that I have no conscience." Neel, Theresa, & Amber
- "The King of Life? You know, the guy we worship? Lives up in the sky?" Exhumations
- "Birch Beer is kinda like Ginger Ale if it were Root Beer." Neel
Game Three
- "Good thing we didn't take the train. Otherwise we might have gotten derailed back there." October, or maybe Andrιs
- "Shoot first, ask questions later. It's not just a motto, it's a way of life." Theresa
- "Hooked on Hashish worked for me." Theresa
- "You put the whiskey in the gumbo, so when you eat the gumbo, it don't eat you." SeptemberBlack?
- "Yeah, she took long-term fallout. It shows." Augusta
- "Well, the King of Life helped us, and he's bigger than themthe spirits." Exhumations
- "You have a dirtier mind than me. And that takes some doing." Theresa, to Alex
- "Now, do you really think the King of Life will like you better if you've had a headache?" "Yes." "This is Ellery we're talking about; she's a carrier of headaches." October, Ellery, & Cyrus
- "People brains are different." "They still work just as well for tanning." Cyrus & Exhumations
- "Brother, you are a Dog, not a God. The letters go the other way." "He's confused from reading Hebrew." September & Exhumations
- "God doesn't talk directly to people; your head would explode!" "No! We're not Catholic." Exhumations & Ellery
- "He's a spirit who rebelled against the King of Life at the beginning of time, and the spirit of Love turned to Wrath." "I win!" September & Ellery
- "You've had a hundred million years to eliminate slavery. Did you just think of this last week?" Exhumations
Game Four
- "Are you one of them watchamacallits?" Sheriff Davis
- "Riots, bad. People dying, generally bad. Reelection, irrelevant." Cyrus Stark
- "Now, technically speaking, is making the rivers run red with blood pollution?" "If it's the blood of the guilty, no. The blood of the innocent, yes." October & Ellery
- "He goes by Red Orc these days. Who knows what his original name is?" "Red Orc-iel? October & Exhumations
- "Lying for Jesus is A-OK." Exhumations
- "Join the Abolitionist cause or suffer from hemorrhoids." October, on summoning the angel of extreme annoyance
- "Prime numbers, even numbers, God's pretty egalitarian when it comes to numbers." Cyrus
- "I'm sooo lost." "It's theology!" Joseph & October
- "Be like Hitler, kids. Don't smoke." Nick
- "Then there's no point in the conflict." "But I rolled so well!" Amber & Alex
- "Stop making demons that appeal to the players, not the characters." Andrιs
Game Five
- "I saw it in a moving picture once." "Those are unrealistic depictions of reality that are disturbing and corrupting our nation's youth." Cyrus & October
- "Oh! Bluff! Tell 'em they're surrounded!" Cyrus
- "Bastards. I'm not shooting to miss anymore." Cyrus
- "Slowly upgrade as you strip?" Theresa & Andrιs, in unison
- "We tried sweet reason, right?" "Uh, yeah, more or less
" Cyrus & Exhumations
- "And the guards start to fall like so many ten-pins with a shotgun." Neel
- "Even betterthen there's no moral responsibility for his death." Exhumations
- "For Orc and freedom!" September
- "Ah, go ahead and lynch them." Ellery
- "If we happen to see Ellery, I suggest we run her over." 'Do you want in on this conflict?" "Nope." Joseph, the GM, & Ellery
- "Somewhere in the Old Testament, bats changed genus." Nick
Game Six
- "Wow, a lot of these NPCs are dead." Neel
- "We didn't kill no women
now mind, we haven't met up with Ellery yet
" October
- "I think they've got an eternal hunger or something, which either justice or babies can satisfy." October
- "Here, have four extra dice for cannibalism!" Neel, the heartless GM
- "Does that make Cyrus the new sherriff?" "It's not like Santa Claus, it doesn't go to the killer." Andrιs and Theresa
- "I can tell it's evil, because Neel wants me to do it." Theresa
- "They caught Exhumations, and they're going to humate him pretty soon!" Some townie
- "You shot my brother!" "I dunno. Who was your brother?" A Deputy & Exhumations
- "Not 'Amber' like me, 'Amber' like the role-playing game, without dice and stuff." Amber
Game Seven
- "I'm almost afraid to ask what's in the quote file." Neel
- "Nah, squirrel balls aren't funny out of context." Theresa
- "That's what god is like." "Arbitrary and capricious?" "We prefer the term 'timeless'." Neel, Theresa & Nick
- "Um, I was worried there for a bit." Exhumations, on being taken out back of the jail, ostensibly to be savagely beaten
- "Hey, I was expecting a total party kill three or four sessions ago." Theresa
- "It's not a fight if she dies right away." Ellery
- "Not only does he get the gun, but it goes off in my leg. Bitch." Ellery
- "You're getting dogpiled, basically." Neel
- "You're like an evil virus." Exhumations, to Ellery, post-mortem